Book Review: The Personal Librarian

This post may include affiliate links, which means we make a small commission on any sales. This commission helps Feminist Book Club pay our contributors, so thanks for supporting small, independent media!

The Personal Librarian by Marie Benedict and Victoria Christopher Murray is an exciting historical fiction novel that dives into the extraordinary life of Belle da Costa Greene, the personal librarian to J.P. Morgan, during the early twentieth century. This gripping tale offers readers a captivating narrative and raises important questions about feminism, social justice, and the power dynamics that women, especially women of color, face in a male-dominated society.

The story follows Belle, a white-passing Black woman who hides her racial identity to navigate the prejudice of the early 1900s. As she climbs the ranks in Morgan’s powerful circle, Belle becomes an indispensable figure in the world of art and literature, curating one of the most prestigious libraries of her time. However, as her career flourishes, Belle must constantly grapple with the limitations imposed on her as a Black woman, facing overt and subtle discrimination.

One of the book’s strongest angles lies in its exploration of Belle’s relentless pursuit of knowledge and intellectual fulfillment. In an era when women’s academic pursuits were often discouraged or dismissed, Belle’s passion for literature and determination to become an expert in her field defied societal expectations. Her tireless efforts to amass an unparalleled collection of rare books and manuscripts showcase her resilience and her refusal to be confined by the limitations imposed on women.

Moreover, the authors highlight the complex intersectionality of Belle’s identity as a Black woman, shedding light on her additional challenges. Belle’s need to conceal her racial heritage speaks volumes about the prevailing racism of the time and the lengths she must go to protect her position and reputation. The book prompts readers to reflect on how power and prejudice intersect, perpetuating inequality and denying marginalized individuals opportunities for growth and recognition.

This book resonated deeply with me, striking a compelling chord that resonated with my own identity. While I can never fully comprehend the profound racism and discrimination that Black women have historically and continue to face daily, I found solace in Belle’s story, particularly in her need to conceal her identity. As a queer white-passing Middle Eastern woman, I have encountered numerous instances where different aspects of my identity have been challenged, undermined, and marginalized. For a significant portion of my life, I suppressed my bisexuality, as many people trivialized my experiences, causing me to believe that certain parts of my identity needed to remain hidden.

Within the pages of Belle’s narrative, I discovered boundless inspiration. Belle was a Black woman occupying the role of personal librarian to one of New York City’s most influential men during an era when women, let alone a Black woman, faced nearly insurmountable obstacles in attaining positions of power. Although Belle had to hide her racial background, she managed to surpass societal expectations and ascend to greater heights than most women of her time. While I can never truly comprehend the complex reality of being a Black woman concealing her identity to advance her career, there is one invaluable lesson that resonates with me deeply – Belle was deserving of so much more than what the world was willing to provide, and despite the myriad barriers she faced, she still succeeded in making a lasting impact for herself and her family.

The Personal Librarian is a thought-provoking and inspiring novel that skillfully intertwines themes of feminism, social justice, and the pursuit of knowledge. Through Belle’s journey, readers are encouraged to reflect on the systemic barriers women and marginalized communities face today. This book serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of fighting for equality, inclusivity, and the recognition of the often-unseen contributions of women throughout history.

Yasi Agah

Yasi Agah websiteYasi Agah LinkedinYasi Agah Instagram

Yasi Agah is a born and raised Californian living out her dreams in New York City. She loves to read, write, listen to podcasts, and teach yoga. Becoming by Michelle Obama makes her cry every time she reads it.